Entrust Business Consultants | Valuation Guide

Valuations Explained

A clear, practical presentation explaining how property valuation methods differ where market evidence is plentiful, limited, or where the property value is closely linked to the business conducted from the property.

Context

Why valuation method matters

The method should follow the nature of the asset and the quality of available market evidence.

Ordinary property can often be valued by looking at market evidence: similar properties, comparable sales, market rentals and yields. Specialised property is different. It may not transact often enough for reliable comparison, and the valuer may need to return to fundamentals: what the asset contributes to the business, how it generates wealth, or what it would cost to replace.

🏢

Non-specialised property

Residential, office, retail, industrial and warehousing property normally have more market evidence and can often be compared directly.

⚙️

Specialised property

Assets such as hotels, petrol stations, churches or public facilities may require profits, residual or cost-based analysis.

📈

Income link

Where the property is integral to the business, sustainable trading performance can become a key valuation driver.

🔍

Evidence first

The valuation approach is only as strong as the quality of market, income, cost and operational evidence behind it.

⚠️
Important: This presentation is an explanatory guide and not a formal valuation report. A qualified valuer should be appointed where a formal market valuation is required for finance, tax, court, accounting, insurance or transactional purposes.
Core Concepts

Price, Market Value and Worth

Much confusion disappears once these concepts are separated.

01

Price

The actual observable exchange amount achieved in the market. It is historic evidence of what a buyer and seller agreed.

02

Market Value

An estimate of the amount an asset should exchange for on the valuation date between informed, willing parties acting at arm's length.

03

Worth

The value of the asset to a particular party, based on that party's expected future benefits, strategy, synergies and risk appetite.

Commercial implication: A seller's expectation, a buyer's internal worth calculation and a valuer's market value opinion may all differ. Negotiation often sits in the gap between those three views.
Purpose

Why the valuation is being prepared

The purpose does not automatically decide the method, but it determines the question the valuation must answer.

Sale / Marketing Advice

A guide to the likely selling price after proper exposure to the market.

Purchase Advice

A buyer-specific view of the best bid, often closer to worth than neutral market value.

Accounting Purposes

A statement of property value as part of the owner's balance sheet on a specific date.

Loan Security

A lender-focused market value used to assess loan-to-value risk.

Auction Reserve / Minimum Price

A benchmark below which the seller may be unwilling or unable to transact.

Insurance

Usually a reinstatement or replacement cost exercise rather than a market sale value.

Taxation

Often formula-driven and may differ from ordinary market value calculations.

Compulsory Purchase

Compensation is generally based on open market value, often involving specialised property.

Valuation Models

The five recognised approaches

Each method is a different way of modelling how a market participant would think about value.

Market evidence

Comparable Method

Best used when: Properties with reliable evidence of previous sales.

Core logic: Value is inferred by comparing the subject property with similar transactions, then adjusting for timing, location, quality, risk and market conditions.

Mainly non-specialised property.
Rent and yield

Investment / Income Method

Best used when: Commercial or residential property producing, or capable of producing, rental cash flow.

Core logic: Market rent or net income is capitalised by reference to an appropriate yield or multiplier derived from market evidence.

Mainly non-specialised income-producing property.
Trading performance

Accounts / Profits Method

Best used when: Trading properties where value is closely linked to the business operated from the property and rental evidence is limited.

Core logic: A sustainable level of revenue and operating profit is analysed to estimate the property contribution, which can then support a valuation.

Specialised trading property.
Redevelopment potential

Development / Residual Method

Best used when: Bare land, redevelopment opportunities, or properties where the highest and best use is a development outcome.

Core logic: Completed development value is estimated, development costs and required profit are deducted, and the residue indicates the land/property value.

Can apply to both specialised and non-specialised property.
Replacement cost

Contractor's / Cost Method

Best used when: Specialised assets rarely sold in the open market, or properties valued for technical, accounting or statutory purposes.

Core logic: Land value plus replacement cost is adjusted for depreciation, obsolescence and functional utility.

Specialised property, especially where profit/rental evidence is unavailable.
Decision Framework

How to choose the correct method

Start with the evidence. The weaker the market evidence, the more the analysis shifts toward fundamentals.

1

Is there reliable comparable evidence?

Use direct comparison or investment evidence where there are sufficient comparable sales, rentals and yields.

2

Is the property income-producing?

If rent or cash flow can be evidenced, the income or investment method may be appropriate. If trading profit drives value, consider the profits method.

3

Is the asset highly specialised?

Where sales, rental and profit evidence are limited, replacement cost or residual logic may be the only rational way to model value.

More market evidence

  • Comparable transactions are observable.
  • Market rentals and yields can be tested.
  • The property is more homogeneous.
  • Valuation can lean on exchange price evidence.

Less market evidence

  • The property rarely sells in the open market.
  • Income is generated by the business operation.
  • The asset has specialised design or use.
  • Valuation must examine worth, cost, profit or redevelopment logic.
Specialised Property

Examples and typical valuation logic

Specialised assets require careful matching between the property type, the available evidence and the valuation model.

Property typeTypical valuation logicLikely method
Agricultural landMarket comparison may be distorted by grants, quota allocations or policy support.Accounts / Profits, sometimes Comparable
Telecommunications facilitiesMasts may have comparables; cabling, relay and booster sites often depend on business contribution.Comparable or Accounts / Profits
Mineral extractionLand is a factor of production and value is driven by likely extraction profit after costs.Accounts / Profits or Residual
LandfillValue is generated by disposal capacity and the income from what can be placed into the ground.Accounts / Profits
Bars and restaurantsWhere comparables are thin, expected trading profit becomes central to the valuation.Comparable, Investment or Accounts / Profits
Casinos and clubsFood, drink, entry fees and gaming or membership revenue drive the property value analysis.Accounts / Profits
Cinemas and theatresEntry fees and concession revenue are analysed as part of the trading property model.Accounts / Profits
HotelsRoom revenue, food, beverage, conference, entertainment and facilities income all contribute.Accounts / Profits
Private leisure propertiesExamples include golf clubs, health clubs, courts, pools and sports facilities where users pay market-related charges.Accounts / Profits, sometimes Comparable or Investment
Public leisure propertiesOften subsidised and non-profit, making profit analysis inappropriate.Contractor's / Cost
Private care / nursing homesIncome-producing care facilities are valued by reference to operating performance.Accounts / Profits
Public care / hospitalsNon-profit public facilities generally rely on replacement cost logic.Contractor's / Cost
Development propertyExisting value is determined through the residual outcome after development value, costs and profit.Residual
Petrol stationsIncome-generating trading businesses where property value is linked to sustainable operational profit.Accounts / Profits
WoodlandsCan be comparable, but often influenced by grants, tax incentives and timber income.Comparable or Accounts / Profits
ChurchesUsually non-profit and charitable in nature, with limited open-market transaction evidence.Contractor's / Cost
Practical Use

Information needed before relying on a valuation

For business acquisition or property-linked transactions, the valuation number must be supported by evidence.

Property and market evidence

  • Title deed, zoning, permitted use and restrictions.
  • Building size, condition, age, functionality and layout.
  • Comparable sales, rentals, yields and market trends.
  • Replacement cost estimates, depreciation and obsolescence factors.
  • Development potential, planning risk and capital expenditure needs.

Business and income evidence

  • Historic financial statements and management accounts.
  • Sustainable revenue, gross profit, EBITDA and occupancy/usage data.
  • Owner adjustments, once-off expenses and maintainable earnings.
  • Lease terms, rentals, escalations and tenant risk.
  • Insurance, finance, tax and compliance implications.
Entrust perspective: In a business sale or acquisition, the valuation method must be explained in plain language so that buyers, sellers, funders and advisors understand what the number represents - and what it does not represent.